Skip to main content

Another reason I can’t really be trans

I recently wrote about a seemingly quite common feeling among those trans folks who have cross dressed before realising that they are trans; that maybe it’s just a fetish that I have got carried away with the idea of. 

To save you the bother of going back and reading the post, I concluded that it was the other way around and the cross dressing came from a wish to be female, not the other way around. 

Of course my brain isn’t going to let me off that easily. Not when I can find other explanations to discredit my feelings of transness. 

I should preface this by saying that I have no knowledge of neuroscience and that everything I am thinking is probably wrong. However, a little knowledge is a dangerous thing and has led me to some worrying thoughts. 

Ok, starting with things I do know about the brain. There is something called neuroplasticity which means brains aren’t fixed, and if you do something very frequently the part of the brain responsible becomes more developed. The best known example of this is cab drivers who get very developed memory and navigational zones in their brains from learning routes. The opposite is also true, parts of the brain that you don’t use become less developed. If you rely on sat nav then your  navigation zone can shrink. I think that addiction mechanisms are not dissimilar, with the parts of the brain responsible for feeling pleasure developing more to respond to the addictive stimulus and so needing more inputs. Like I said, my neuroscience is shaky at best. 

How is this relevant?

Well, in short, what if I wasn’t trans but by my actions have taught my brain to think it is?  Could what I think of as my trans journey actually just be an escalation of an addiction and each step just further develops the need for the next?  Have I just made myself think that I’m trans and therefore it isn’t real? 

And if that’s the case, do I fall into the category of “false transsexual “ or autogynephile that Blanchard wrote about? I’m not going to start on that particular controversy, don’t worry, but I bring it up because when I happened to read about that classification and was feeling these concerns, it sort of felt like it explained me. I think the author of that and similar categorisations of trans people have caused a lot of angst to a lot of people. 

I used to be nervous just going into female clothing shops to look around, then I was terrified buying female clothing thinking everyone knew I was “wrong” in some way. Eventually I managed to ask to try on a dress and was practically shaking with fear, but it went fine and the next time I wanted to try on a skirt, I was relaxed about it. So much so. I braved a bra fitting, so much more exposed and personal but I coped and I could do it again without fear. Is that working through barriers and overcoming fears by learning that it’s not as bad as I imagined? Or is it upping the ante to get the same excitement from the fear? 

In truth I don’t really know whether I am taking steps on my journey or escalating an addiction. I like to think that it is the former and that I am overcoming fear rather than seeking thrills. I’m not consciously seeking thrills that’s for sure, I’m pushing myself to face challenges.  A couple of years ago, I was scared to join a trans forum or to write down in an email to a friend that I thought I might be trans. Even saying the word to myself was terrifying but each time I did, it got easier.  Is that making myself think something or just becoming comfortable with something I already felt? 

Now I can say I am trans and I want to become a woman.  Easy.  And I truly mean it, that is what I want. But this nagging doubt in the back of my mind keeps saying “that’s not real, that’s just what you want to think”. Which I appreciate is a bit of a circular argument. 

Does it really matter? If, through years of cross dressing, a bit of fetish and a lot of fantasising about being a woman, I have made my brain trans by over developing some part of it, then that is what my brain is now and it doesn’t matter whether it was trans or not when I first put on my mum’s bra to feel like the girls in my class, it is now. 

I suppose the counter to that would be that if I have taught myself to be trans, can I undo it and teach myself to be cis?  That’s another controversy to leave well alone I think.  All I can answer for myself is why would I want to do that?  I absolutely love my transness and being Nicola for real and forever is my dream.  No part of me has any desire to be a real man (whatever that means). 

What have we learned? 

I may or may not have made myself feel trans. I can’t know for sure, but I still think the feelings of wanting to be like the girls came first. 

It probably doesn’t matter whether I have always been trans or have made myself so, that’s what I am now. 

Also, I am not qualified to talk about neuroscience but my brain is very good at learning a little and then using it to stress me out. 

And yet my brain also tells me I am a woman. 

I think it all comes from fear of what happens if I act on that feeling and finding reasons why it might not be true is a good way of preventing me from having to face that.


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

11 Feb 2024 - how do you open a “coming out” conversation?

Feeling better today and woke up feeling feminine which was nice. Wife still in bed.  I could come out, but only to the dog! Went for a run instead.  2.75 miles which is 0.5 miles more than last week but the last bit was a struggle. We talked a bit but I didn’t say what I need to say. Now she has gone to shower.   I also didn’t say anything in the afternoon and then failed to say anything in the evening too. The problem is that it isn’t the sort of thing that neatly segues into a conversation. “Funny that you should mention penile inversion vaginoplasty…” is unlikely to ever come up as an opportune opening.   And it is the opening sentence that I think is the hardest part.  That is the moment of “shock” so needs to be not too shocking. After that, I think I will find the rest fairly easy as it is just telling my story.   I think that “I’m transgender” or anything like that is too big a shock statement.  I think that a softer introduction of “I wish I w...
Post a Comment
Read more

21 Jun 24 - more correspondence from the gender clinic

I got details if the voice feminisation therapist through on the email and also links to the BMA and GMC guidance for GPs so I can do battle with the practice and see if they will help with my treatment by prescribing and doing the blood tests.  The voice coaching letter is interesting. It seems it’s not just talking in a higher pitch but also about resonance and it is that which makes the most difference. Which makes sense. The are women with high voices and low voices but they are all immediately identifiable as female, so there must be something other than pitch that signals this.  They also train for conversation, telephone and projection / public speaking as you use your voice differently in these situations.  Sounds interesting, maybe fun and most likely difficult to master.  I was visiting our northernmost office today and was hoping to be able to go out at the Mall on the way home, but there wasn’t enough time to fit that in. I am keen to have some more ...
Post a Comment
Read more

15th August - why transition?

I ended yesterday‘a post with a question: if I can find joy in just occasionally seeing myself as a woman, why would I want to upset my whole life and go through the emotional and physical pain of transitioning?  Is this a good question? Or is it just my protective brain once again trying to prevent me from taking a risky step? Could be both?  Assuming it is a valid question to ask myself, what are the arguments for not transitioning?  I have managed to live my life with my secret for decades and I am fine. When I do get to dress femme, I like it and it brings me happiness, and occasionally real joy. Real life is mundane and I am sure that dressing female all the time will not bring me perpetual joy and happiness, it will just be my normal. With suitable underwear and the right style of clothing, I can achieve the outward appearance of a female body shape and look pretty good (mainly thanks to the advantage of height relative to size). I don’t need hormones or surgery to ...
Post a Comment
Read more